Custom-Finish Coffee Tables: Round or Square?
From the sofa, a coffee table is mostly a plane. You see the top at a shallow angle, the light lying across it, and very little else. Walk past the same table on the way to the kitchen and the top disappears: what registers instead is the side of the piece, the legs, the shadow beneath it. Two tables can share a height, a made-to-order wait and the same promise of a finish you choose, and still be read in opposite ways, depending on which of those two views your room gives them.
That is the useful way to think about a custom finish. On both of these Ambella cocktail tables the custom part is the surface, not the plan: the Lachlan 53" Round Cocktail Table- Custom Finish Option is fixed at 53 inches round and the Everard Cocktail Table- Custom Finish Option at 50 inches square, both 18 inches high, both made to order with four to six weeks allowed for custom finishing production. What you are choosing is a color you have not stood next to the piece. So the first question is not which finish. It is how much form you are handing that finish to work with.
A Round Top Gives the Finish Nothing to Hide Behind
The Lachlan gives the eye very little to hold on to. A 53-inch disc sits 18 inches off the floor on four cylindrical legs whose rounded caps stay visible above the top, and the base stays open underneath, so a rug runs beneath the table and the floor shows through it. At 70 pounds, there is more air in this table than mass. There is also no molding, no relief and no pattern — one large plane, four straight lines, and 53 inches of surface whichever way you cross it, which makes the footprint easy to plan and the top hard to disguise.
So the finish does all of the describing. A single uninterrupted field of color across 53 inches is as unforgiving as a bare wall: it has to be a tone you can live beside every day, and its only texture is what is already in the surface. The photograph shows the table in Graphite Cerused Finish — dark, matte, with fine linear grain running through it — a finish that reads as one quiet color from across the room and only separates into grain up close. Choose it because you want that calm; nothing in the form is going to help a color you are unsure of.
Where the Finish Has Somewhere to Go
The Everard asks more of the eye. Its top is 50 inches square rather than round, and beneath it the table closes into a plinth body cut with a repeating geometric relief — diagonals and vertical bars alternating across the front. In the photographs it is a greige and medium gray piece, two cool neutrals that on a flat surface would read as merely quiet.
Here they have help. Carving breaks a finish into two readings at once: the flat face of each shape, where the color sits plainly, and the channels cut between them, where the same color becomes shadow and line. Because the pattern is cut rather than printed, it changes as you move through the room and the light shifts across it. A pale greige that might look washed out over the Lachlan's uninterrupted disc has something to describe on this body, while a very dark finish would fill the carving in and reduce the base to a single silhouette — a heavier, quieter effect.
The rest of the table follows from that solidity. At 135 pounds the Everard is close to twice the Lachlan, and its closed plinth sits on the floor rather than floating above it, so the piece reads as a block the rug stops at. A square also reaches further than its side suggests: 50 inches across the face, roughly 71 inches from corner to corner, and it is those corners that meet a walkway first. Where the Lachlan's footprint is the same 53 inches in every direction, this one wants a little more clearance than its width implies.
Ordering a Finish You Have Only Met in a Photograph
Both tables are made to order, with four to six weeks allowed for custom finishing production. Nothing about the plan changes in that window; the finish is applied after you commit to it. That makes the photograph you chose from do a great deal of work, and the two tables are not equally helpful in the same way. The Lachlan's image is labeled with the finish it shows — Graphite Cerused — so you carry a name to the swatch. The Everard's greige and grays are not named, so what you are matching is a tone you have seen rather than a word you can repeat.
The order that saves a second decision is form first, finish second. A color chosen with a carved plinth in mind will not behave the same way on a flat disc, and the reverse is just as true. Picking the finish before you know which table will wear it means choosing for a surface you have not settled on.
Which One the Room Is Asking For
If the table will sit in the middle of a seating group, seen mostly from the sofa and from above, and the room already carries plenty of pattern, the Lachlan is the quieter answer: 53 inches round, an open base, and a surface that wants a finish you would be happy to paint a wall in.
If the table will be walked past more often than sat at, and you want its side to carry the room, the Everard's carved plinth gives your finish somewhere to go; a mid-to-light tone lets the cut shapes show, while a deep one closes them up. Keep the boundary in mind either way: custom, on both tables, means the finish. Neither changes its size, and neither offers a top made to your own measurement — the plan is fixed and the choice begins at the surface.
Shop the story
For a broader look at shape, proportion and materials, see Crate & Barrel’s coffee table buying guide.
Leave a comment